On a Home Base Steamboat closing, the city's payment appears on the closing statement as consideration for a deed restriction.
That wire comes from short-term rental guests. Steamboat voters approved a 9% STR tax in November 2022, and the City Council paid for the $3 million Home Base pilot out of it. Breckenridge built its rental charge differently, and a lawsuit over that choice is now before the Colorado Supreme Court. Taken together, the two towns show how their rental charges differ, and how Steamboat's is starting to change what some local buyers bring to the closing table.
Two checks, and the one every buyer took
Home Base has no income limit. The city's June 16, 2026 announcement laid out two options:
| Resident-occupied restriction | Appreciation-capped restriction | |
|---|---|---|
| City contribution | Up to 15% of purchase price | Up to 25% of purchase price |
| Dollar cap | $150,000 | $250,000 |
The Yampa Valley Housing Authority runs the program with the city.
The bigger check comes with a capped resale price, and so far no buyer has taken it. Steamboat Pilot & Today reported on Oct. 27, 2026 that five purchases had closed with nearly $586,000 in city contributions. Three more households were under contract and expected to close by mid-November, which would bring the city's total to just over $1 million. All eight participants chose the local-residency restriction.
Those numbers also hint at the price range. Five closings and roughly $586,000 average out to about $117,000 per home. If those buyers took the full 15%, the average purchase price would be about $780,000, and higher if anyone took less.
Where the wire comes from
The city's STR Tax Fund page says the money is dedicated to increasing affordable and attainable housing, including incentives at places like Brown Ranch, plus the infrastructure that housing needs. The city's OpenGov budget dashboard, updated Nov. 9, 2026, shows how much the tax brings in:
- 2024 actual: $15,251,648 in taxes and assessments, plus $854,943 in investment income
- 2025 year-end projection: $15,543,779 in taxes and assessments
- 2026 budget: $15,386,337 in taxes and assessments, plus $1,125,000 in investment income
Spending is a different picture. The same dashboard shows $5,118,065 spent in 2024, a 2025 year-end projection of $673,850, and no spending in the original 2026 budget. The city says money is appropriated as Council approves projects. Its estimated fund balance at the end of 2026 is $52,558,411. That figure is a budget estimate, not an audited balance.
The money has gone out in large blocks so far. In January 2025, the Yampa Valley Bugle reported three early commitments:
- A $5 million grant to the Yampa Valley Housing Authority for a third building at Cottonwoods at Mid Valley, intended to shift it toward for-sale deed-restricted homes for households earning 100% to 140% of area median income.
- A $2.6 million loan at 2% interest to Gorman & Co. for Riverview, in exchange for the city getting first access to 11 units.
- $2.5 million toward the Casey's Pond rescue, which secured 15 workforce units.
Home Base works differently. It pays out one buyer at a time, at closing, and so far for homes in the existing market. The city has also chosen CHAI Funds as its financial services partner for a rolling solicitation program that will take applications for STR tax money on an ongoing basis.
The rental side is softening. The city's Nov. 2, 2026 sales tax release put September 2026 STR tax collections down 13.7% from September 2025, a drop of $89,636. Lodging sales tax fell 14.06% over the same comparison. One month is not a trend, and September is a shoulder month. Still, rental owners paying the tax and local buyers receiving Home Base checks both depend on the same lodging demand.
The lawsuit is about how a town labeled its charge
Breckenridge took a different route in 2021. The Town Council passed an ordinance creating an annual per-bedroom charge on short-term rentals, labeled a regulatory fee, which Steamboat Pilot & Today reports has risen to $756 per bedroom as of 2026. Alexander Dorotik, a Denver attorney who owns a short-term rental in Breckenridge, sued in September 2024. He argues the charge works like a tax, which would have needed voter approval under Colorado's Taxpayer's Bill of Rights.
The Summit County District Court dismissed the case, and the Court of Appeals agreed. On Oct. 19, 2026, the Colorado Supreme Court agreed to hear it. The court limited its review to whether a government can charge a fee on an activity that brings in more tax revenue than it costs, and whether the lower court misread the 2018 ruling that upheld Aspen's paper-bag fee.
Steamboat's charge started at the ballot box. The city's 9% STR tax took effect Jan. 1, 2023, after voters approved it on Nov. 8, 2022. Steamboat Pilot & Today's election-night count showed it leading 62.7% to 37.3%. The Breckenridge case asks whether a charge that skipped the ballot was really a tax, and Steamboat's housing money began as a tax voters approved.
Dorotik himself told the Pilot that a win would not automatically spread to other towns:
"Hypothetically, if I'm successful in Breckenridge, and another jurisdiction like Telluride has essentially the exact same fee, that doesn't mean that automatically it disappears, but it is really subject to legal challenge."
He named Telluride, Basalt and Granby as towns with fees that partly resemble Breckenridge's. Basalt's $2,532 per-bedroom fee, adopted in 2025, also funds workforce housing. Margaret Bowes, executive director of the Colorado Association of Ski Towns, told the Pilot that 16 of 39 CAST communities surveyed in 2024 collected a tax or fee on short-term rentals, and that the case "could have far-reaching consequences throughout Colorado's tourism-dependent communities." The timeline is long. Dorotik told the Pilot a ruling is "very unlikely" in less than a year.
Reading it from either side of the deal
A second-home buyer comparing ski towns sees a 9% tax in Steamboat and a per-bedroom fee in Breckenridge. They look like the same kind of cost on a rental budget. One is now in front of the state's highest court, and the other started as a ballot question.
On the receiving end, each night a guest stays in a Steamboat rental adds to the fund that wires money to a title company when a home in city limits is purchased through Home Base. Eight households had used it by late October, all choosing the local-residency restriction. In its Oct. 27 report, Steamboat Pilot & Today said the city was working to add two pathways expected to launch this fall: one letting local employers buy up to two homes for their employees, and one letting existing homeowners place a deed restriction on their properties.
Quick answers
Does Home Base Steamboat have an income limit? No.
Can the money be used for a home outside town? The city's announcement says the home must be within Steamboat Springs city limits.
Is the Breckenridge case challenging Steamboat's STR tax? The case is Dorotik v. Town of Breckenridge, Colorado Supreme Court No. 26SC283, and it concerns Breckenridge's per-bedroom regulatory fee. The Pilot's coverage does not name Steamboat Springs or Routt County.
This post is general information, not legal, tax or financial advice. Before acting on a deed restriction, a rental tax or a court case, please confirm how it applies to you with an attorney, accountant or lender.
Whether you're weighing a Steamboat rental against another ski town or considering a purchase in city limits, The Labor Long Team can help you explore homes. Start Your Steamboat Search.